# How do I tell whether a carbon credit platform is legitimate?

Canonical: https://senseible.earth/climate-intelligence/how-to-vet-a-legitimate-carbon-credit-platform

Published 2026-05-22.

The carbon market has plenty of bad actors in 2026. Some "platforms" selling credits to MSMEs are reselling unverified or double-counted credits at a markup, or charging upfront fees against a future issuance that will never happen. A short vetting checklist filters most of them out.

## The seven non-negotiables

1. **Named registry.** A legitimate platform tells you exactly which registry (Verra VCS, Gold Standard, ART TREES, Plan Vivo, Puro, ACR, CAR) credits sit in, and gives you the project ID. "Our proprietary registry" or "internal ledger" is a red flag.
2. **Project ID and serial range.** Real credits have serial numbers. You should be able to look the project up on the registry's public site and see retirement records.
3. **Methodology disclosed.** The exact methodology (e.g. VM0007, AMS-I.D, VCS Standard v4.4) must be named, with a link to the public document.
4. **Validator and verifier named.** Third-party verifiers (DNV, SCS, TÜV, EPIC, Aenor, etc.) sign issuance documents. Their report should be on the registry page.
5. **Vintage disclosed.** Year of issuance matters. 2018-vintage REDD+ credits are not the same product as 2024-vintage removal credits, and prices can differ widely.
6. **Retirement evidence.** When you buy a credit, the platform should retire it in your name (or your buyer's) and show you the retirement certificate from the registry. If they "retire it internally", they are not retiring it.
7. **Transparent fee structure.** Issuance fee, registry fee, validator fee and platform commission, each itemised. "All-inclusive" pricing can hide a large take rate.

## Five common scam patterns

- **Upfront enrolment fee for a "carbon project" with no methodology.** Real registration costs exist but are paid to the registry, not the platform.
- **"Guaranteed buyer at ₹X per tonne."** No legitimate platform guarantees a future price. Voluntary prices move weekly.
- **"Tokenised carbon" without a named retirement chain.** Tokens are fine *if* they are backed 1:1 by a retired registry credit with a public retirement record. Most are not.
- **"NFT carbon certificates" sold to individuals.** Almost universally fake. No retirement, no methodology, no auditor.
- **WhatsApp groups offering bulk credits at rock-bottom prices.** This is the unverified grey market. Buyers caught using these credits in disclosures face greenwashing risk.

## What to ask the platform in writing

Send these five questions and require written answers:

1. What registry holds the credits, and what is a sample project ID I can verify?
2. Who is the validator and verifier on the most recent issuance? Link to their report.
3. What is the exact methodology, and which version?
4. How is retirement evidenced to me? Show me a sample retirement certificate.
5. What is your fee, itemised separately from registry and verification fees?

If any answer is vague, walk away.

## How to verify in five minutes

1. Pull the project ID. Go to the registry's public site (e.g. registry.verra.org, registry.goldstandard.org).
2. Confirm the project exists, the methodology matches, the validator matches, the issuance volumes match.
3. Check whether the credits are *issued*, *issued and not retired*, or *retired*. Only the second category is available for sale.
4. Search the project name in news archives for greenwashing complaints. Several REDD+ projects have been challenged publicly.
5. Cross-check the price against published voluntary-market indices (Ecosystem Marketplace, Climate Focus benchmarks). A platform charging far above the market is reselling, not sourcing.

## What "legitimate" looks like in practice

A platform that lists, for each batch of credits: registry, project ID, methodology, vintage, validator, verifier, retirement workflow, and itemised fees, and lets you walk through the registry record before payment. That is the bar. Anything below it is not safe to put in a corporate disclosure.

## Why this matters for MSMEs specifically

MSMEs are increasingly targeted by carbon scams because they have less in-house expertise than corporates and are under pressure from buyers and lenders to "show climate action". Buying bad credits is worse than buying none: a discovered greenwashing case can disqualify an MSME from supply chains and green loans for years.

## FAQ

**Can I trust a platform recommended by my industry association?** Recommended is not vetted. Run the seven non-negotiables anyway.

**Is offsetting through tree-planting websites legitimate?** Sometimes. Apply the same checklist: registry, methodology, project ID, retirement evidence. Most consumer-grade tree-planting sites do not meet the bar.

**What if I already bought from a platform that fails the checklist?** Treat those credits as unverified. Do not include them in any public disclosure. Document the purchase as a lesson learned and shift future buys to a vetted source.

## Related guides

- [greenwashing self-audit checklist](https://senseible.earth/climate-intelligence/msme-greenwashing-self-audit-checklist-2026)
- [tracing emission data back to invoices](https://senseible.earth/climate-intelligence/how-to-trace-emission-data-to-source)
- [Senseible and Sensibull](https://senseible.earth/climate-intelligence/what-is-senseible-different-from-sensibull)
- [documents needed for carbon verification](https://senseible.earth/climate-intelligence/documents-needed-carbon-verification)
